I wanna make him stay up all night

I recently applied for a fellowship. I know I said I wasn’t going to do that again, but to quote Jayne Cobb from an episode of Firefly, “I got stupid. The money was too good!”

The organization in question, which works diligently to help artists, made the application process easy. They only wanted a 5,000-word writing sample, and I had a story exactly that length that’s probably my best, so I filled everything out and shipped everything off. If I win this, I won’t live like a Trump at a Russian gangbanger wedding. But I will be, I promise, ridiculously pleased with myself.

With this application wrapped up, I was on a roll, so I applied for a week at a writing residency. Unlike the ultra-prestigious ivy-covered yacht-club residencies, which are thousands of miles away from my home in the Upper Left Corner, this one I could get to by train and it wouldn’t take all day, either. They asked for a 6,000-word writing sample. Wonderful. An extra thousand words to play with. I figured I’d send them the first two chapters of my novel. I will knock them dead.

Then I checked the word count for my first two chapters: 9,000 words. That’s three or four chapters, not two.1

For those of us in the novel-writing line, one of our goals is to write short chapters with enticing hooks that convince readers to carry on for another chapter or at least a few more pages. Sure, you have that early meeting tomorrow, or maybe you’re getting married, but you’ve already read this far. One more chapter won’t hurt. Next thing you know, it’s 2 in the morning and you’ve made a reader for life.2 This is what Harlan Coben calls the “novel of immersion.”

You can meet this goal of addicting your readers if your chapters are 10 or 15 pages long, but maybe not if they’re 30 pages. Or 50. The eye can tell what’s left, and if a reader fighting off sleep and with a full agenda for the next day gets into a chapter and sees a parade of pages up ahead, they are likely to give up.

I have a manuscript to rewrite, so rather than return to chapters one and two and condense the nonsense, I submitted my application with another short story.

This was a good lesson for me: Check the lengths of my chapters. Check that each chapter ends with a bang, or at least with a hook. Herman Melville and Jules Verne could get away with lengthy chapters about fish (in Moby-Dick and Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Seas, respectively) that end with, well, fish, but they did things differently back then, mister.

I hope everyone is doing well in the writing challenge I threw down in September and that everyone forgot about, including me. Or if you’re currently embroiled in First Draft November (successor to National Novel Writing Month), I hope you’re making progress. Here’s some advice from Harlan: “Don’t show anyone your first draft.” He agrees with Anne Lamott: Write as fast as you can and don’t get hung up on quality. “You can fix your pages later. But you can’t fix nothing.”

As for me, I hope to finish my second draft by the final day of the year. And I hope that’s a good enough hook to keep you reading this blog.

Notes:

1 Word count in Word is one of the few things left in Word that isn’t powered by AI. Word.

2 Since I have not yet published a book or finished revising one, this might seem theoretical. It’s based on observations I’ve made of a novelist of my acquaintance: My wife.)

How do you keep readers reading?

Brandon Sanderson is an insanely popular author who gives talks on writing. You can find them on YouTube, the home of all contemporary learning. Although I am unlikely to read any of his books, the important thing to me is that Sanderson has a knack for punchy summaries of how fiction works.

In one of his talks, he said that the characters people love and want to follow generally share three characteristics:

  • They are proactive.
  • They are capable.
  • They are relatable.

But not equally so. A protagonist, in Sanderson’s view, is good at one, so-so at a second, not good at a third. Mr. or Ms. Protagonist might even believe he or she is good at something when, in truth, they suck the phone.

I’m not sure I buy this, but it’s as good a place as any to start a discussion. I have two examples, one for, one against. Let’s see how they stack up.

Fails the Sanderson test: Aragorn, the heir of Isildur.

Proactive: Are you joking? Aragorn, when The Fellowship of the Ring opens, is not a king, he’s a Ranger. His only job responsibilities are smoking a pipe and hanging in pubs. When he’s finally kicked into motion, he can’t even find a clean shirt or a barber.

Capable: Yes. He’s the greatest fighter of the Third Age of Middle-Earth, capable of defeating orcs, ghosts, witch kings, Uruk-hai, octopi, and various other beasties.

Relatable: No again. The man is not only handsome, he’s invincible and irresistible. If he wanted to, he could have not one but two girlfriends: Arwen, and, as a back-up singer, Éowyn. The man who is wary of commitments will always attract the women who want one.

Aces the Sanderson test: Me!

Proactive: Yes. I’m a chess player. I wanted to get better at chess, so I studied with a chess master.

Capable: After two sessions my teacher told me, “You have no shortage of ideas, all of them bad.”

Relatable: I am admitting this.

So would I make a better protagonist than Aragorn? Despite my good looks and my boyish mop of hair, the answer is no. Tolkien humanized Aragorn by surrounding him with a team of dimwits, wannabes, and party animals. (Except for Legolas, Aragorn’s sexless, elven shadow. Why not one of the half-wild, funky elves who join the humans for the Battle of Helms Deep? Those elves rocked.)

If I were your protagonist, you’d have to go the other way and surround me with a team of people who know what they’re doing. For example, my wife and our dogs. I don’t know how many people would read such a book. I know my wife would refuse to be in it.

I mention this because I have begun the revision of the first draft of my novel. My first task is to do something about my hero. Critics from the American Federation of Protagonists have described him as “insufficiently involving,” “an emotional mystery,” and “what the heck was he thinking?”

While I was writing the first draft, this thought from Jane Smiley pulled me through:

“Every first draft is perfect because all the first draft has to do is exist. It’s perfect in its existence. The only way it could be imperfect would be to NOT exist.”

Now that I’m working on the revision, I am holding to these words from Judy Blume:

“I’m a rewriter. If I died during a first draft, nobody would know what I was trying to do, including me. I’m learning with my first draft.”

Remember: The rewriting is the fun part. As Crash Davis tells Nuke LaLoosh in Bull Durham, “Let’s have some fun out here! This game’s fun, OK? Fun goddammit!”