This weekend I’m tending to the sick (impaired mobility) and rewriting a story that never went anywhere (impaired narrative). When you’re not on top of your game, life is about as workable as stale Play-Doh. So I’m taking a break to flame a big fat piggy target. No, not Donald Trump, Pam “Smooth Operator” Bondi, or the alarming idea that people might actually want to vote. I refer to the plight of the white male writer as described by Jacob Savage in “It’s Hard Out There for White Male Writers” in Compact, March 21, 2025.
“Over the course of the 2010s, the literary pipeline for white men was effectively shut down,” Savage claims. Normally, I wouldn’t bother with this self-righteous effluvium, but Savage was quoted by columnist Ross Douthat in our paper of record, The New York Times, so I say let’s grab this fucker by the pussy.
(Note: E-ffluvium sounds like my dotcom, where I was going to become a millionaire. However, the first recorded instance in English of effluvium, in the sense of an emanation or a release of something toxic, was in 1651. A shame that William Shakespeare died in 1616. Bill would’ve given effluvium to either Dogberry or Falstaff and he would’ve thought up a hilarious 17th-century rhyme that we’d still be writing papers about today. What that man couldn’t do with six flights of stairs and a runaway harpsichord!)
“White male millennials, caught between the privileges of their youths and the tragicomedies of their professional and personal lives, understand intrinsically that they are stranded on the wrong side of history—that there are no Good White Men,” Savage whines, and in way too many words. Unfortunately for Mr. Savage, his essay appeared a couple of weeks before White Male Millennial Andrew Martin, author of two novels and a short story collection, published a story in The New Yorker.
As I understand it, The New Yorker is the Great White Whale for writers. It certainly is for me. Perhaps the Great White Male Writer still has some lead left in his pencil.
Thus Savage (who, among other things, proves that he knows next to nothing about science fiction, which he calls “a deep authorial remove from the real world”) joins the ranks of white male writers who yearn to be free of some unnamed, unidentified oppression. James Patterson, who has sold more books than anyone since King James and who is about as white and male as a white male can get this side of Mickey Spillane, complained about the same amorphous shit in 2022, a year when only a sad sliver of all books were written by white males: a microscopic 75%.
I’m sure this Tenth Avenue freeze-out was news to three of Patterson’s white male contemporaries, Andy Weir, Chuck Pahlaniuk, and Stephen King, all of whom seem to be coping just fine with the current literary environment despite whatever it is that’s trying to diminish them or cancel them or kidnap them and fly them to a distant planet for nefarious purposes that somehow involve breeding.
Has literature changed radically since Patterson’s privileged bitching in 2022 and Savage’s in 2025? My unscientific research says Yes! Since my last name begins with a B, I looked at the letter B in the list of Knopf Doubleday’s authors. I also threw in a few writers at the end of A and the beginning of C, because reading these things was like eating potato chips. There are 235 of these creatures, and judging by their first names and photos, 135 are white guys. That’s only 57%. Avengers assemble!
And this fortress of white male fortitude is even smaller than it looks because some of the white males on the Knopf list are dead: Richard Adams, Harold Bloom. Some of them are really dead: James M. Cain. Two of them were photographed with their dogs, two wore stupid hats, and one was Bono. Plus Nicholson Baker looks exactly like Frank Herbert and George R.R. Martin. Join us next time for: More white guys.
White males once ruled publishing. They wrote most of the published books, because they were Ernest Hemingway but also because most of the editors were white males. We have many people writing and publishing books today who are not white and not male. If this diverse atmosphere is too competitive for you, perhaps you should try another line of work, like high desert nudist or sub-inspector of nuisances. Or maybe you should work harder and write better? That’s what I’ve always assumed my rejections meant. Just a thought.
Spoilers: I’m white, I’m male, I’m good (or good enough), and I didn’t become a millionaire.







